Most board reviews are a survey. Everyone fills it in, a report comes back with averages and five recommendations, and the board resolves to do better. Twelve months later the same issues are on the same agenda.

We do a different thing. We talk to people, read what the board actually decides, and tell you what we found.

What you are buying is not a report. It is the thing your board has not been able to say to itself.

Who is doing the reviewing

Forty-five years of governance between us — twenty-five for Rāwā, twenty for Frankie. Not consultants who studied boards, but directors and trustees who sit on them now, currently chairing one board and serving as a trustee on another, with a member of the Institute of Directors on the team.

That matters in a specific way. We have sat through the meeting where the hard thing did not get said. We know what a board paper looks like when it has been written to secure approval rather than to inform a decision. We can tell the difference between a board that disagrees well and one that has stopped disagreeing.

A board is not its constitution. It is what it actually decides, and who is in the room when it does.

How we work

Every review is built on the same method: issue, rules, analysis, conclusion — with te Tiriti o Waitangi and the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities treated as part of the rules rather than as a separate cultural section at the end.

The analysis step always asks the same question: who is missing, and who carries the risk of this decision? That is where most governance failures are visible well before they become incidents.

What a full review involves

  • Terms of reference agreed with the board before anything starts, so everyone knows the scope and what will be reported.
  • A data access protocol, so it is clear what we will read and what we will not.
  • Confidential interviews with directors, the chief executive, and where it is useful, staff and the communities the organisation serves.
  • Participant information and written consent for everyone interviewed. People speak honestly when they know exactly how what they say will be used.
  • Document review — constitution, delegations, board papers, minutes, risk and conflict registers.
  • Observation of at least one board meeting, where the board is willing.
  • A written report with findings, and recommendations that name an owner and a timeframe.
  • A facilitated session with the board to work through it, because a report nobody discusses changes nothing.

What we review

Governance health check

A short, honest read. Document review and a conversation with the chair and chief executive, and a brief written report. Good when something feels off and you want a view before committing to anything larger.

$3,900 + GST

Board effectiveness review

The full process above. Interviews, documents, observation, report and board session.

from $12,000 + GST

Spotlight review

One question, examined properly. A chair or chief executive transition, a conflict of interest that has not been handled well, a risk register nobody believes, a founder who has not let go, or a board whose composition no longer matches who it serves.

$6,500 + GST

Te Tiriti and inclusion review

Whether your Tiriti commitment exists in decision rights, procurement, data and budget, or only in the strategy document. Can be run on its own or built into a full review.

from $8,500 + GST

Implementation support

Most reviews fail at the recommendation stage. We can stay on to help the board actually do it.

$2,400 + GST per day

Community and kaupapa pricing. Community organisations, marae-based services and disabled people’s organisations pay what the work is worth to them, and we carry pro bono reviews every year. Boards doing the hardest work usually have the least to spend on looking at themselves, which is exactly backwards. Ask.

How long it takes

A health check is back with you inside two weeks. A spotlight review takes four weeks. A full board effectiveness review takes eight weeks from the day terms of reference are signed, including the board session.

Those are commitments, not estimates. If we are going to miss one, you will hear it from us before the date, not after.

The fee does not move. We agree terms of reference before anything starts, and we quote against them. If the work turns out to be larger than we judged, that is our problem rather than a variation on your invoice. If the board wants the scope widened mid-review, we will tell you what that costs before we do any of it.

Independence, and when we will say no

A review is worth nothing if the reviewer is compromised. We will tell you before we start if either of us has a connection to your board, your sector or your people that could affect the work, and we will decline if that connection is close enough to matter.

We will also tell you at the outset what we will do if we find something serious. We do not write around findings to keep a client comfortable.


Starting a conversation

Email kiaora@kwbandco.com or call 027 THE KWBs (027 843 5927). Tell us what prompted it — a resolution, an incident, a transition, a funder asking questions, or a feeling that the board is busy but not governing. All five are normal starting points.

Governance reviews are provided by Karetai Wood-Bodley & Co under its terms of engagement.